Movie and movie character is truest to their book counterpart

Page 2 of 2 Previous  1, 2

View previous topic View next topic Go down

Which Movie is truest to its film counterpart?

40% 40% 
[ 2 ]
20% 20% 
[ 1 ]
40% 40% 
[ 2 ]
 
Total Votes : 5

Re: Movie and movie character is truest to their book counterpart

Post by Ally on Tue Aug 09, 2011 12:47 pm

Lorient Avandi wrote:
Pettytyrant101 wrote:Yes, if memory serves Theoden goes from "Why should we ride to the aid of those who did not come to our aid?" to; Aragorn- "Gondor calls for aid!" Theoden- "And Rohan will answer" without anything inbetween.
Its a little more dramatic than that
Early movie scene
Gandalf- if the beacons are lit, Rohan must be ready for war
Theoden- Tell me-why should we ride to the aid of those who did not come to ours?......... Or do we owe Gondor?

Later, after Aragorn rushes to the Hall after seeing the beacon
Aragorn- the beacons of Minas Tirith are lit! Gondor calls for aid!
Theoden- *hesitates*.....And rohan will answer!


Hey Lorient! I love your avatar btw! Everyone knows that the most attractive men come from Gondor! Razz
avatar
Ally
Wannabe Beard

Posts : 2758
Join date : 2011-02-13
Age : 21
Location : It's nice when you have enough hair to use as a pillow.

Back to top Go down

Re: Movie and movie character is truest to their book counterpart

Post by Orwell on Tue Aug 09, 2011 1:28 pm

Ally wrote:Having recently watched the films again while going on a few extremely long journeys (driving to Poland from Wales? Why? Then Poland to America? Stupid!!)

Great car, though! Shocked

_________________
"Skirts!" cried our respectable Master Odo. "Skirts! And they have the temerity to call them 'kilts'.... Eru darn my socks!"

From "The True Tale of the Un-magical Coal Scuttle."
avatar
Orwell
Dark Presence with Gilt Edge

Posts : 8567
Join date : 2011-05-24
Age : 98
Location : Ozhobbitstan

Back to top Go down

Re: Movie and movie character is truest to their book counterpart

Post by Pettytyrant101 on Tue Aug 09, 2011 3:23 pm

"I also had a few thoughts on the whole Helm's Deep thing while watching. In the books they have to go the deep to avoid a humongous army of orcs and
dunelendings which were charging across Rohan, a force so huge that Theoden could not help to defeat them in a pitched battle. But then in the movie Gandalf was like "Hey Theoden! Don't be such a coward!" And I was like, "being a coward by not meeting them to all get killed?!"- Ally

Go PJ! Yeah this is another one of those 'this makes no sense at all ideas' he throws in there. In his version of events Gandalf thinks the small amount of people in Edoras would be better not gathering forces and riding to a stronghold but that they should ride out and meet Sarumans enormous army out in the field- where the Rphirrim would be slaughtered within about 10 minutes- why he thinks this, why PJ decided to make Helms Deep 'a trap' is yet another pathetic example of where he was unable (or unwilling) to get suitable drama from the source and felt he had to 'add' some in. Mad

_________________
Pure Publications is Reasonably Proud to Present the first ever Forumshire novel!

Gingerlocks and the Three McTyrants

- get your copy here for a limited period- free*



*Pure Publications reserves the right to track your usage of this publication, snoop on your home address, go through your bins and sell personal information on to the highest bidder.
avatar
Pettytyrant101
Crabbitmeister

Posts : 39458
Join date : 2011-02-14
Age : 46
Location : Scotshobbitland

Back to top Go down

Re: Movie and movie character is truest to their book counterpart

Post by Lorient Avandi on Tue Aug 09, 2011 6:19 pm

Another flaw with the helms deep bit is that in the book, there are a few thousand rohirrim there, but in the movie there are only 300+200 elves.this doesn't make sense considering they have 6000 in ROTK and they were still expecting more. It would have been better to at least have 2000-3000.
avatar
Lorient Avandi
Wizard of Magicland

Posts : 728
Join date : 2011-08-08
Age : 21
Location : Utah, USA

Back to top Go down

Re: Movie and movie character is truest to their book counterpart

Post by Lorient Avandi on Tue Aug 09, 2011 6:28 pm

Ally wrote:


Hey Lorient! I love your avatar btw! Everyone knows that the most attractive men come from Gondor! Razz
Thanks!
avatar
Lorient Avandi
Wizard of Magicland

Posts : 728
Join date : 2011-08-08
Age : 21
Location : Utah, USA

Back to top Go down

Re: Movie and movie character is truest to their book counterpart

Post by Eldorion on Tue Aug 09, 2011 8:23 pm

Ally wrote:Reading the book I found Theoden to be noble yet kind (the opposite to Denethor really) but when I watched the movies again, having read the books, I found him too young. Maybe the character wasn't developed enough.

I agree on this; both Theoden and Theodred appeared to have been de-aged by about 20 years for the films. In the books, Theoden was in his 70s and still and old man even without Wormtongue around, and Theodred was already in his 40s. In the films, Theoden appeared to be in his early 50s at most (post-exorcism), and Theodred in his mid-late 20s. I've no idea why PJ thought he should to change that.

I also had a few thoughts on the whole Helm's Deep thing while watching. In the books they have to go the deep to avoid a humongous army of orcs and dunelendings which were charging across Rohan, a force so huge that Theoden could not help to defeat them in a pitched battle. But then in the movie Gandalf was like "Hey Theoden! Don't be such a coward!" And I was like, "being a coward by not meeting them to all get killed?!"

I agree, and I also think it's also worth noting that in the books Theoden did want to fight Saruman's army head-on, but decided to face them from the protection of the Hornburg because he realized, as you say, that he couldn't hope to defeat them in the open field. He did not take the entire population of Edoras with him; they were (IIRC) evacuated to Dunharrow, which was much closer to Edoras and more importantly did not require marching the mass of helpless civilians towards armies of marauding orcs and wargs. Apparently tactical stupidity is also dramatic now. Razz

For all my complaining though, I do still enjoy TTT, and I think that Helm's Deep is a fantastic cinematic battle sequence, even if I roll my eyes at some of the contrived drama and tension. Smile
avatar
Eldorion
You're Gonna Carry That Weight

Posts : 22629
Join date : 2011-02-13
Age : 23
Location : Maryland, United States

http://nolondil.tumblr.com/essays

Back to top Go down

Re: Movie and movie character is truest to their book counterpart

Post by Eldorion on Tue Aug 09, 2011 8:24 pm

Lorient Avandi wrote:Another flaw with the helms deep bit is that in the book, there are a few thousand rohirrim there, but in the movie there are only 300+200 elves.this doesn't make sense considering they have 6000 in ROTK and they were still expecting more. It would have been better to at least have 2000-3000.

Yeah, I never really got that either (except as more "drama"). Maybe PJ had been reading 300 before shooting Helm's Deep? Shrugging
avatar
Eldorion
You're Gonna Carry That Weight

Posts : 22629
Join date : 2011-02-13
Age : 23
Location : Maryland, United States

http://nolondil.tumblr.com/essays

Back to top Go down

Re: Movie and movie character is truest to their book counterpart

Post by chris63 on Wed Aug 10, 2011 12:44 am

I think PJ said Helms deep reminded him of Zulu



What a brilliant movie, gave me goosebumps just watching this clip.
Would have to put this in my top 5 movies.


Last edited by chris63 on Wed Aug 10, 2011 12:53 am; edited 1 time in total
avatar
chris63
Adventurer

Posts : 7243
Join date : 2011-07-04
Location : Perth, Australia

Back to top Go down

Re: Movie and movie character is truest to their book counterpart

Post by Orwell on Wed Aug 10, 2011 12:49 am

Eldorion wrote:
Lorient Avandi wrote:Another flaw with the helms deep bit is that in the book, there are a few thousand rohirrim there, but in the movie there are only 300+200 elves.this doesn't make sense considering they have 6000 in ROTK and they were still expecting more. It would have been better to at least have 2000-3000.

Yeah, I never really got that either (except as more "drama"). Maybe PJ had been reading 300 before shooting Helm's Deep? Shrugging

I admit to feeling a bit of a buzz when the elves turned up (don't tell Petty I said it!) though it was wrong, ever so wrong. I now watch it and cringe.

_________________
"Skirts!" cried our respectable Master Odo. "Skirts! And they have the temerity to call them 'kilts'.... Eru darn my socks!"

From "The True Tale of the Un-magical Coal Scuttle."
avatar
Orwell
Dark Presence with Gilt Edge

Posts : 8567
Join date : 2011-05-24
Age : 98
Location : Ozhobbitstan

Back to top Go down

Re: Movie and movie character is truest to their book counterpart

Post by Pettytyrant101 on Wed Aug 10, 2011 1:06 am

Mad

Shame he didn't watch Zulu closer the difference between it and Helms Deep is it was good.

_________________
Pure Publications is Reasonably Proud to Present the first ever Forumshire novel!

Gingerlocks and the Three McTyrants

- get your copy here for a limited period- free*



*Pure Publications reserves the right to track your usage of this publication, snoop on your home address, go through your bins and sell personal information on to the highest bidder.
avatar
Pettytyrant101
Crabbitmeister

Posts : 39458
Join date : 2011-02-14
Age : 46
Location : Scotshobbitland

Back to top Go down

Re: Movie and movie character is truest to their book counterpart

Post by Tinuviel on Wed Aug 10, 2011 2:44 am

I liked Helms Deep, except that there were no elves left at the end Suspect but I never even noticed until I was older... hmmm... silly PJ, underestimating his audience AGAIN.

_________________
"I think that many confuse 'applicability' with 'allegory'; but the one resides in the freedom of the reader, and the other in the purposed domination of the author." -JRRT

avatar
Tinuviel
Finest Nose

Posts : 1937
Join date : 2011-02-15
Age : 22

Back to top Go down

Page 2 of 2 Previous  1, 2

View previous topic View next topic Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum